Should All, Or Parts, of the NWS Be Privatized?

An advertisement by WSI for the for-profit, fee-based
NWS Nexrad Service 

Today was Day 3 for the unavailability of NWS radars along the northeast Gulf Coast (they finally came up about 2pm Eastern time). While the radars were available to the controlling NWS office, they could not be used by anyone else. This was just the latest of the increasingly common NWS/NOAA fiascos that started about 20 years ago and have become much, much worse in recent months. 

The NWS has no announced plan to fix this. In fact, the NWS has indicated it has no interest in improving the radar network. 

While the radars were unavailable, flash flooding was occurring in the area. There is some threat of a tropical storm or hurricane the end of this week. The Weather Channel's legendary meteorologist Jim Cantore offered a suggestion on Twitter/X Monday morning:


One would have thought he suggested tearing down the Statue of Liberty. "Free" weather -- no matter how poor the quality -- is treated like part of the Bill of Rights to some. These are just a few of the 120+ comments. Note, especially, the one at the bottom:
While the latest issue is comms -- which has practically been a weekly issue the past two months -- these radars are 30 years old. They frequently fail. Given their timeline, the NWS's replacement plans won't have the new ones in place until the existing radars are 50 years old! They aren't even going to announce how they want to replace them until 2028!

Realizing the status quo is unacceptable, Jim made a positive suggestion and it instantly made him a "corporate stooge" -- one of the silliest things I've ever heard. Jim is a solid guy trying to help.

Now, let's get to the merits of Jim's suggestion. Please consider:
  • You pay for your physician's services and you pay for "lifesaving" medicine. 
  • You pay for a smoke detector and fire extinguisher. 
  • In many areas, you get a bill after the fire department puts out a fire at your home. 
Why should radar, especially when it is frequently unavailable, automatically be free? 

From the early 1990's to January 1, 2001, NWS Doppler radar came with a fee! Direct access was limited to four companies (it soon became three) and you had to sign up with one of the those companies and pay a monthly bill to get NWS radar. And, guess what? The Republic survived! 

Since 2012's Hurricane Sandy, I have advocated for a National Disaster Review Board (NDRB) modeled after the hugely successful NTSB. Now, I am starting to wonder if it is too late. The NWS is literally falling apart. The leadership of the NWS and NOAA seem unable to react in a constructive manner. They can't even launch weather balloons (something that a high school student can do) on schedule. Perhaps it is time to reconsider how weather information provided in the United States. People are dying as a result of the status quo. 

We have discussed these ideas in the past and I don't care to rehash them again today. But, it is time to immediately move forward with the NDRB and to start thinking about what comes after the National Weather Service. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

7am MST Updated Southwest Flood Information

Monday Tornado and Flood Forecast